Choose a self-inflating camping mat by checking sleeping width and length, cushioning, verified insulation guidance, packed dimensions and carrying weight. A thicker mat is not automatically warmer or more comfortable for every sleeper. Measure your tent bedroom or bed platform before choosing a size.
This World of Camping guide compares two spacious individual mats, the Outdoor Revolution Camp Star Midi 10cm and Vango Arcadia 7.5 Grande, for Cornwall campsite holidays, UK touring and campervan trips.
Quick answer: which self-inflating mat should you choose?
- Consider the Camp Star Midi if a 198 × 76cm surface and 10cm foam depth suit your setup.
- Consider the Arcadia 7.5 Grande if a 200 × 76cm surface, 7.5cm depth and lower listed carrying weight appeal.
- For two separate mats, allow 152cm nominal combined width, plus the clearance your tent needs.
- For colder trips, check insulation evidence and your complete sleeping setup, not thickness alone.
- For a campervan or camp bed, compare actual supported dimensions rather than assuming a size name guarantees fit.
What is a self-inflating mat?
A self-inflating mat, often called a SIM, contains foam inside an airtight shell. Opening the valve in its inflation setting allows the foam to expand and draw air in. Follow the exact manufacturer's instructions for first use, final firmness, closing the valve and packing away. Self-inflating does not mean every model reaches your preferred firmness without adjustment.
A conventional airbed uses air-supported construction rather than the same foam-filled design. Neither type is universally the best choice. Read our self-inflating mat vs airbed buying guide for the broader comparison.
Camp Star Midi vs Arcadia Grande: specification comparison
Both selected listings were available to buy when checked on 25 October 2026. Check each product page for current prices, availability and full details. This is a specification comparison, not a claim based on personal testing.
| Detail | Outdoor Revolution Camp Star Midi 100 | Vango Arcadia 7.5 Grande |
|---|---|---|
| Product | Camp Star Midi 10cm | Arcadia 7.5 Grande |
| Open dimensions | 198 × 76 × 10cm | 200 × 76 × 7.5cm |
| Listed weight | 4.1kg | 3kg |
| Packed dimensions | 81 × 20 × 21cm | 77cm long × 22cm diameter |
| Valve | One Cyclone one-way valve | Cyclone Flip Valve |
| Surface and construction | Peach polyester top and base with PVC coating; horizontally drilled flat foam | Soft-touch flocked top and 75D non-slip polyester base |
| Insulation information | A verified R-value is not established in the supplied specifications | Product specification states R-value 7.4; the test basis is not established here |
| Carry bag | Listed as included | Confirm supplied packing accessories if required |
The Arcadia is 1.1kg lighter on the listed figures; the Camp Star has 2.5cm more foam depth. Those differences do not establish which will feel better or be warmer. Without comparable verified insulation evidence, this guide does not rank their thermal performance.
1. Measure sleeping width and length first
Both mats are 76cm wide. Check whether that gives you enough usable space in your normal sleeping position. Compare the 198cm and 200cm lengths with your own needs, bedding and the space inside your tent.
Two of either model have a combined nominal width of 152cm. Two Camp Star mats need a nominal 198 × 152cm footprint, while two Arcadia Grande mats need 200 × 152cm. Allow additional clearance for sloping walls, doors and kit. A two-person tent label does not guarantee either pair will fit.
2. Choose cushioning without assuming warmth
Depth describes the mat's inflated thickness, not a minimum comfortable temperature. Comfort also depends on firmness, usable width, foam construction and your sleeping position. Side sleepers should check whether their shoulders and hips remain supported at their preferred firmness.
The Camp Star Midi provides a listed 10cm depth; the Arcadia Grande provides 7.5cm. Choose by fit and feel rather than assuming the deeper mat is automatically better. A camping mat should not be treated as a medical treatment for back problems.
3. Check insulation separately
For insulation comparisons, look for tested R-values on the same test basis and manufacturer guidance for the expected conditions. The Arcadia listing states an R-value of 7.4, but this guide does not establish its test basis. A verified comparable figure is not established for the Camp Star Midi.
Do not translate the stated R-value into a guaranteed air temperature or assume winter suitability from foam depth. Check your sleeping bag, clothing, forecast, exposure and complete sleeping setup. Read our autumn sleeping-mat guide covering thickness, insulation and comfort.
4. Compare packed size and carrying weight
The Camp Star Midi packs to a listed 81 × 20 × 21cm and weighs 4.1kg. The Arcadia Grande packs to 77cm long × 22cm diameter and weighs 3kg. Measure your storage opening as well as the space inside the car, caravan or campervan.
For a pair, the listed mat weights total 8.2kg for two Camp Star Midis or 6kg for two Arcadia Grandes, before additional packaging or equipment. Assess carrying distance carefully. Do not assume either is a lightweight backpacking mat.
5. Confirm camp-bed and campervan compatibility
If placing a mat on a camp bed, compare its length and width with the bed's flat, supported platform and follow both manufacturers' instructions. A 76cm-wide mat should not be assumed suitable for a narrower bed merely because it can physically be placed on top.
For a rock 'n' roll bed, measure the actual sleeping platform, hinges, shaped edges and available headroom. Neither Grande nor Midi confirms compatibility with a particular van conversion. Our rock 'n' roll bed mattress guide explains further fit checks and specialist mat options.
Inflation, firmness and packing away
Read the exact valve instructions before the first trip. Allow time for initial foam expansion, use the correct valve setting and close it as directed. The names Cyclone and Cyclone Flip do not establish identical operating steps or universal pump compatibility.
No built-in powered pump is established for either compared model in the specifications used here. Check manufacturer guidance before connecting an external pump or adding pressure. Do not use an unverified pressure setting or assume a precise inflation time.
For packing, follow the model-specific deflation and rolling method. Do not force a closed valve or use excessive pressure to make the mat fit its bag. Follow cleaning, drying and storage instructions, protect the shell from sharp objects and heat, and check repair guidance before departure.
Other sleeping-mat guides
For single versus shared 7.5cm Vango formats, read our Arcadia Grande vs Double comparison. For deeper comfort-focused options and insulation checks, use the autumn mat guide. For foam-filled versus air-supported construction, see SIM vs airbed.
Choosing a sleeping mat in Cornwall
World of Camping is at 4 Bamber House, Victoria, St Austell, Cornwall, PL26 8LQ. Bring your tent-bedroom or bed-platform dimensions and storage measurements when seeking advice. Contact us before travelling to confirm opening hours and whether a particular mat is available to view or try. Purchase stock does not guarantee display availability.
Self-inflating mat FAQs
What size are these two mats?
The Camp Star Midi is 198 × 76 × 10cm. The Arcadia 7.5 Grande is 200 × 76 × 7.5cm. Both are spacious individual formats, not confirmed two-person sleeping surfaces.
Is a 10cm mat warmer than a 7.5cm mat?
Not necessarily. Thickness alone does not establish insulation. Use comparable verified R-values and manufacturer guidance rather than assuming the deeper mat is warmer.
Which has the lower listed carrying weight?
The Arcadia Grande is listed at 3kg, compared with 4.1kg for the Camp Star Midi, a difference of 1.1kg.
Will two fit in a two-person tent?
Not automatically. Two 76cm-wide mats need 152cm nominal combined width, plus clearance. Compare full lengths and widths with the usable sleeping compartment.
Does the Camp Star Midi include a carry bag?
Yes, a carry bag is listed as included. Its packed dimensions are 81 × 20 × 21cm.
Do self-inflating mats need an electric pump?
The two models compared use foam expansion and valves. Follow their exact instructions for initial inflation and firmness adjustment. A built-in powered pump is not established for these models; other mat designs may differ.
Can I connect any pump to either valve?
Do not assume universal compatibility. Confirm the connector and approved inflation method with the manufacturer before using a pump.
Can I put either mat on a camp bed?
Only after checking the supported platform dimensions and both manufacturers' guidance. A matching size label is not enough to establish compatibility.
Which is best for side sleepers?
There is no universal winner. Check usable width, firmness and support under hips and shoulders in your normal sleeping position. Extra depth alone does not guarantee comfort.
Is either mat guaranteed for winter camping?
This guide does not establish a guaranteed winter temperature for either mat. Check verified insulation evidence, manufacturer guidance and your complete sleeping system for the intended conditions.
Our recommendation
Start with a mat that fits. Compare the Camp Star Midi if its 10cm depth appeals and its packed size and 4.1kg weight suit your transport. Compare the Arcadia 7.5 Grande if its 200cm length, soft-touch top and 3kg listed weight suit your priorities. Choose insulation for the trip separately, and confirm missing details before ordering.